A Sufferer from TDS (Tomato Deprivation Syndrome) Dreams about the Days of Brandywines and Roses

Ugly but sooooooo good tasting

Ugly but sooooooo good tasting

My favorite garden catalog arrived this week. I am an unabashed lover of tomatoes – real tomatoes that I grow in the summer, not the tough, tasteless orbs that pass for tomatoes in supermarkets this time of year.

So I immediately flipped the pages until I found the tomato section and began gazing longingly at glossy photographs of dear friends from the bygone days of summer.

There was Moskvich, dainty and round, not the best-tasting tomato, but the earliest, a trait that endears the variety to me. And Brandywine, of course, whose pinkish, lumpy, deeply creased fruits are hands down the homeliest tomatoes in my patch, but whose flavor is unequaled: An earthy balance of sweet and tart, the distilled essence of a warm sunny afternoon.

I reconnected with a rainbow coalition of old pals – Black Krim, Cherokee Purple, Sun Gold (soooo sweet), Yellow Pear, Green Zebra, Great White. Then I reminded myself that this tomato-y bounty was for the moment only on paper. The pleasures elicited by the catalog were eight months and one long, dreary New England winter away. Seed companies really know how to hurt a guy.

The tomatoes piled so attractively in the produce section of my local supermarket look every bit as tasty as the ones pictured in the catalog, but I know better. Biting into those out-of-season fruits, often picked while still green, gassed with ethylene to make them look ripe, and trucked hundreds of miles, would be no more rewarding than chewing the pages of the catalog.

The sad truth is that for the past half-century, commercial tomato breeders have concentrated on creating varieties that give tremendous yields of tough-skinned fruits. Flavor was simply not a consideration. One grower truthfully told me, “I get paid by the pound. I don’t get a cent for taste.” As a result, tomato yields today are triple what they were in the 1970s, but the genetic material that delivers flavor has been lost.

Fortunately, there’s hope for those of us who suffer from TDS (Tomato Deprivation Syndrome).

Over the last few years, newcomers have begun appearing in the tomato sections of grocery stores. Called salad tomatoes, these fruits are small – about the size of golf balls – and grown in greenhouses. While they don’t deliver anything close to the full flavor wattage of an August Brandywine and cost more than $4 a pound, they do taste like tomatoes.

Salad tomatoes are sold under the brand names Campari and Backyard Farms. I use them as emergency backup, substitutes when canned San Marzano tomatoes can’t work in a recipe.

The other good news is that the breeders who develop seeds for commercial tomato producers have at long last awoken to something the rest of us have known all along: Supermarket tomatoes don’t taste good. They are now developing varieties that can stand up to the indignities of industrial harvesting, packing, and shipping, yet still retain some traces of taste.

In a couple of weeks, I will place my 2012 seed order. It will include all my old tomato friends, and those glossy pictures and hyperbolic descriptions will seduce me into trying a few new ones.

Almost certainly, I will purchase more varieties than I can accommodate in my garden. And on a warm afternoon next summer, I will spy that tell-tale shade of red among my green vines. Standing in the garden and biting into the season’s first real tomato, I will be reminded that life’s greatest pleasures are worth waiting for.




Available Now in Print and Electonic Formats

Click here to place an order with Amazon

Click here to place an order with Barnes & Noble

Click here to place an order with Indiebound

Click here to place an order with Powell’s

Post to Twitter


  1. Kathy in Middleton, WI says:

    Had 105 tomato plants this season at our farm and I miss everyone of them! At least their bounty is safely packed into jars as juice, ketchup, chutney, salsa, and pizza sauce. With the excess, I ran a “tomato avalanche” fundraiser for my son’s school, giving away buckets of fresh tomatoes in return for donations. I also held a tomato canning class that went up for auction at the school, a great social day of busy hands. So, I have fond memories of tomatoes as the foundation of a community building “win win.”

    I will start my seeds again in March, warming them with a heat mat and cover until they prove ready. They’ll be up-potted and gradually moved outside. In May I’ll get them in the ground. It all seems so far off. Sigh! I feel Barry’s pain…

  2. Eden Balfour says:

    I agree, Barry. The only time I buy tomatoes in winter is when I am bringing a dish to a friend or family that has been requested and contains tomatoes. We get by on canned until we can have The Real Thing from our garden. Experimenting with season extension is on my to-do list. And storage – a friend says she can keep Manitoba tomatoes in her cold storage until January in northern Canada.

Leave a Reply