Not-So Candid Cameras: Supermarket Films Protesting Farmworkers’ Kids

IMG_2611

After more that 15 years of petitions, demonstrations, hunger strikes, and lobbying efforts, members of the Coalition of Immokalee Workers (CIW), a group trying to alleviate the abysmal labor conditions in Florida’s tomato fields (including slavery), take adversity as a given in their battle to secure living wages from the giant corporations that control the state’s produce industry. Florida grows the vast majority of winter tomatoes consumed in this country, so it’s a fight in which everyone who eats a fresh tomato during the cold months has a stake.

But a recent series of events has left the coalition feeling baffled, queasy, and angry.

For the past several weeks the CIW has been holding demonstrations at stores operated by Publix Super Markets, Inc., a Florida-based company that operated more than 1000 markets in five Southeastern states. Publix has been unresponsive to years of requests that it join the coalition’s Campaign for Fair Food, a program that mandates steps to prevent human trafficking and gives field hands a one-penny-per-pound raise (hardly a princely sum to a $24-billion a year corporation like Publix, but enough to add $20 to a picker’s $50 daily take, the difference between abject poverty and a living wage).

IMG_2598

At an evening vigil in front of the courthouse in Ft. Myers, where a year earlier several members of a Southwestern Florida family were convicted of enslaving 12 immigrant tomato workers, CIW member Greg Asbed felt a presence behind him as he snugged a blanket around his son, who was nodding off to sleep in a stroller. Asbed wheeled around and came face-to-face with a stranger pointing a video camera over his shoulder directly at the child’s face. The cameraman did not identify himself.

A day later, while walking a picket line in front of a Publix in Sarasota, Lucas Benitez, another CIW member, noticed that a cameraman focused on his one-year-old baby each time that Lucas passed him. “I thought it was kind of weird because he didn’t identify himself or say anything,” said Benitez in a telephone interview. “I was worried.”

During a Port Charlotte demonstration, Jordan Buckley, a supporter of the CIW, wondered why store officials were allowing one particular photographer unfettered access, while preventing others from filming at all on company property.

“Why are they letting you shoot,” Buckley asked. “Do you work for Publix?”

“No,” said the photographer, whose name was Thomas McGuigan. “I’m just an old hippie doing a documentary about the modern protest movement.” When Buckley got home, he did a quick Google search and found that a person named Thomas McGuigan was employed at Publix video division.

Could there be an undercover spy at work who had an obsession with very young children?

“I wonder how Publix PR people would feel if they were in the same position—if there was a stranger who was found later to be falsely identifying himself filming their children?” said Benitez, when I spoke to him.

“The bottom line for me is, spy on me, well, shame on you, that’s wrong. But spy on my kid, what need does Publix have for that?” said Asbed.

Both questions struck me as a worthwhile, so I made a call to Maria Brous, Director of Media and Community Relations at Publix’s Lakeland headquarters. She confirmed that McGuigan was indeed an employee of Publix, but said that he also owned a separate video production operation and was filming the CIW actions as a personal project. “We did not assign him, but we were aware that he was there. We like to document activities at our stores. It is typical for us to video-record events at our stores—positive ones, too—so we asked Tom to give us a copy we could keep ourselves.”

Brous said that the store did not intend to destroy or give the footage of children back to the parents. “I think it’s unfair to claim that we did anything inappropriate. The children were there as part of the event,” she said.

As to the CIW’s bigger question: Why won’t Publix, whose stores are as ubitquitous as palm trees in the Sunshine State, join a campaign for fair food that is supported by the state’s governor, Charlie Crist, fast-food outlets such as McDonald’s, Burger King, Subway, and Taco Bell, as well as Wholefoods Market, Compass Group (a huge nation-wide food service corporation), and East Coast Growers and Packers, a major Florida tomato producer and packer? “We have a long-standing policy of not intervening in labor disputes,” said Brous.

That reasoning does not wash with the CIW. “We are not asking them to get involved in anyone’s dispute,” said Asbed. “What we’re saying is that there are now big tomato growers out there that are doing the right thing. We are saying buy from them and support them. It’s not a dispute. It’s an option.”

The events of the past few weeks are reminiscent of some corporate shenanigans directed toward the CIW a year and a half ago when the organization was putting pressure on Burger King, another Florida-based firm. An Internet writer who went by the screen name surfxaholic36 accused the worker’s group’s leaders of pocketing donations. But Amy Bennett Williams, a reporter with the Ft. Myers News Press who should get a Pulitzer for her dogged work on labor abuses in Florida’s tomato fields, discovered that the web alias was used by one Shannon Grover, who just happened to be the middle-school-aged daughter of Stephen Grover, a Burger King Vice President. When Williams reached Shannon Grover, the girl denied authoring the posts, saying, “that was my dad.”

Burger King eventually joined the Campaign for Fair Food. Stephen Grover is no longer with the company.

For its part, Publix does seem to have learned one lesson from the current filming furor. Last weekend when the CIW picketed a store in Clearwater, they were once again met by film crews. Asbed said they were more assertive than ever. Only this time the cameramen all wore white buttons bearing the inscription, “I (heart) Publix.”

Post to Twitter

7 comments

  1. Julie Rubaud says:

    Creepy. Nice work Barry.

  2. Nani says:

    Barry, I’m so glad you are now writing a blog about the difficult issues surrounding our country’s food production. Bravo for continuing to report on the tomato pickers and their worthy fight. I will spread the word!

    Best, Romney (Nani)

  3. Callie LaDay says:

    Hi! Fantastic site, I really like your writing style. Very distinctive and concise. On a lot of blogs people just drone on and on, but not you – very nice. I found your site while looking for another one on Google. I don’t have time to read all the recipes right now, but I have bookmarked your site and will visit again very soon to see the latest. I love reading about cooking, it is my favorite hobby. The recipes on your site are incredible. I can’t wait to try them out on my family. They think I’m nuts (and maybe they are right lol) when they see me at work in the kitchen. Visit my site if you’d like to read more. Thank you again for a very educational web site. Keep up the great work!

  4. John says:

    So they hired someone to video the protesters. O.K.

    But “focusing on the baby”? Give me a break. Consumer cameras are autofocus by default, so I don’t he was doing anything specific to focus on the baby. But I assume you mean the less technical sense of focus, zoom in on? In all likelihood, with the standard focal length of a video camera, the frame included the baby and everything around the baby. The baby maybe took up 2 or 3 percent of the image area. So the guy was “focusing” on a protesters. One of whom brought his baby along. I suspose he might have zoomed in on the baby, but really, how would the protester have known what focal length was being used?

    It was in the interest of the protester to make it seem as creepy as possible, and you the journalist didn’t even turn on your brain and think about whether he might not have been exagerating or lying.

  5. Freebie says:

    Thanks for the useful info – I had fun reading it! I always enjoy looking at this blog. :)

Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. Greenhoof » Blog Archive » From Gourmet’s conscience to the decade’s best breweries, tasty morsels from around the web
  2. Farmworkers Score major Victory in the Fight for Fair Treatment

Leave a Reply