Rainforest Action Accuses Cargill of Clearcutting Virgin Trees for Palm Oil Plantations. Cargill Denies the Claims. Who Do We Believe?

Beats me.

Beats me.

Wake up in the morning. Enjoy a warm, soapy shower. Eat a bowl of cereal, perhaps with soy milk. Dab on some lipstick . . .

Perform any of those mundane tasks and chances are you’ve done your bit to destroy a patch of rainforest somewhere in Indonesia where vast stands of virgin trees have been cut, bulldozed, and burned to clear land for palm oil plantations. Once used primarily in cosmetics, palm oil, which is free of artery-clogging trans fats, has become the ingredient du jour in processed foods. In the United States, consumption of the stuff has tripled over the past five years. Growing oil palms is now the largest cause of deforestation in Indonesia contributing to global warming and destroying crucial habitat for the country’s endangered orangutan population, which has fallen by half since the onset of the palm-oil boom.

Early this month, the San Francisco-based Rainforest Action Network (RAN) published a scathing report linking Cargill, Inc., the United States’ importer of palm oil, to rainforest destruction. Cargill sells oil to large food companies like General Mills, Nestle, and Kraft. The Network followed up with a demonstration at Cargill’s Minnesota headquarters, during which seven protestors were hauled away by police.

Rainforest Action accuses Cargill of violating the principles of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), an eco-certification group that includes members from the industry (Cargill is a prominent one) and environmental organizations. Of the many charges in the report, the most surprising was an allegation that Cargill, in addition to owning two large palm plantations in Indonesia, secretly owned and operated two other plantations that are clearing and burning rainforests. The report also said the company was buying additional palm oil from companies “closely associated” with rainforest clear-cutting.

“Cargill is trying to have their cake and eat it too,” said Leila Salazar-Lopez, campaign coordinator for the Network. “While Cargill is proclaiming their commitments to RSPO standards, they’re going ahead and doing whatever they want to rainforests, waterways, and community lands.”

Cargill responded with a statement entitled “Cargill Sets the Record Straight on False Accusations Made by RAN.”

“The title pretty much sums it up,” Lori Johnson, a Cargill spokeswoman, said in an interview. “There are a lot of allegations in the report, but not of them are true. Some of the accusations are simply ludicrous, like we have secret plantations some place. The answer to that’s just no,” she said.

In a response to Cargill’s outright denial, RAN stood firm. “No one wishes more than we do that Cargill wasn’t destroying rainforests. Pictures and maps don’t lie, however,” The organization said in a release. “We stand by the evidence released in our report that Cargill’s plantations in Indonesia are cutting down rainforests, violating the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), and are out of compliance with Indonesian law.”

What’s a conscientious consumer to do? Amid this flurry of accusations and counter-accusations, it’s important to remember one fundamental truth. The palm oil industry in general still has a long way to go before it can be called sustainable. Palm oil may be good for our circulatory systems, but there’s no denying that it’s wreaking havoc on the environment.

Post to Twitter

1 comment

  1. palm oil says:

    Oil Palm plantations are growing at rapid rates in the tropical nations of Indonesia and Malaysia. These lands were once covered by upwards to 90% rain forest just a century ago, while that has declined presently to less than 50%. This is due largely to oil palm plantations. Palm oil has been used historically as a cooking and cosmetics additive with other uses. However, the palm oil industry is now booming with its realization of clean energy. Europe has turned to this clean energy in hopes of reducing the global warming problem. Palm oil is about 8-10 times as efficient as ethanol for power. However, rainforests are being slashed and burned at record rates in these nations, to make room for more palm oil plantations. These areas which were a rich are for trees and plants as well as animals are now being turned into an oil palm monoculture for profits. Think about how the atmosphere is effected when dense rain forests are being burnt down at blinding speeds.

Leave a Reply